By Ralph Ciprianofor BigTrial.net
The feds trotted out one of their star cooperating witnesses against Rufus Seth Williams today.
Mohammad Ali is the Bucks County business man who was allegedly bribing the Philadelphia District Attorney with gifts that included a $205 Louis Vuitton tie, a $3,000 chocolate-colored sofa from Raymour and Flanagan, $4,000 vacations to Punta Cana, and a $7,000 "loan" that was never repaid.
But after the soft-spoken and deferential Ali got through telling his story, he sounded more like the victim of a shakedown who was getting robbed blind. Anybody doing the math would have to wonder what Ali got in return for the money and gifts that he was showering Rufus with. To many courtroom observers, Ali looked like a chump who got played.
It all added up to a puzzling day in court. Rufus Seth Williams, the district attorney of Philadelphia, is not on trial for being a sleaze ball or shakedown artist. If he was, he'd be convicted already. But in a case that hinges on quid pro quos, the feds appear to still be searching for one.
Ali had millions of dollars moving in and out of his accounts. That's why the feds had him under surveillance every time he walked through an airport. But in the end, the feds clipped Ali on a tax rap for not paying $163,000 in back taxes. They also got him to plead guilty to bribing Seth Williams. But they never did nail him for money laundering.
On the witness stand, Ali had to be told over and over again by the judge to speak up. During his testimony, Ali referred to the D.A. as "boss,""boss man," and "Mr. Seth."
Ali's story was that he met Williams at one of the D.A.'s campaign events in 2010. Ali said he wanted to cozy up to Rufus because for a simple reason: "status." He wanted to be "friends with the D.A.," he said.
So Ali donated $2,500 to Williams' political action committee. That got the D.A.'s attention. What was Ali trying to do, the prosecutor asked again, to reiterate that talking point to the jury.
He was trying to "get close to him," Ali said about the D.A. Because he figured that "someone in power" might be useful if "you ever needed anything."
Ok, whatever. But Ali, by his own account, had several problems that he wanted Rufus Seth Williams to help him with. There were those annoying security searches at the airport, where the feds would detain Ali up for up to two hours. While they took his phone away for up to two weeks so they could search it.
As far as Ali was concerned, he was the victim of "racial profiling," he told the jury.
The immigration status of Ali's wife was another problem when she got turned down for citizenship. Ali was also angry about a former employee who had stolen $20,000 from him.
So Ali began showering Rufus with gifts like a Burberry watch, and trips to Punta Cana.
Why was he doing these things, the feds asked?
"Part of it was to be friendly," Ali testified. "Part of it was to get close to the D.A."
OK, we got it.
In court, the judge could have rapped the knuckles of the prosecutors, like he often does the defense lawyers, every time they got repetitive.
But Judge Paul S. Diamond is an unashamedly pro-prosecution judge. It's easy to tell by the objections from the defense, 90 percent of which are overruled by the judge.
The judge has admonished lead defense lawyer Thomas Burke for standing up when he makes an objection.
Today, when Burke got excited about cross-examining a homeland security officer, the judge told Burke, "don't fight with the witness" and "lower your voice."
But for the prosecutors, with Judge Diamond, it's been clear sailing.
Why, the prosecutor asked, was Ali testifying against Rufus?
"To get a reduced sentence," Ali said. He's looking at up to eight years in jail.
So what did the D.A. do to help Ali?
Williams, Ali said, made a phone call to the Bucks County D.A. to get after that former employee who stole $20,000.
Williams also arranged a meeting with Congressman Bob Brady's staff to help out Ali's wife with her citizenship problems.
Certainly Rufus could argue that these were just constituent services he would have done for anybody.
The prosecutor took pains to show how Ali went from being a complete stranger to Rufus in just eight months to becoming Rufus's new best friend while they took vacations together.
Ali and Rufus always traveled first-class, staying at 5 1/2 star resorts in Punta Cana. Two royal ocean-front suites. Palm trees. Private beaches. Swiss massages.
"Did you offer to pay," the prosecutor asked.
"Yes," Ali said.
Rufus was more than happy with the accommodations.
"I am not picky," he texted Ali.
"You are a good man Seth," Ali wrote back.
Did Williams ever offer to pay, the prosecutor asked.
"No," Ali said.
When it came to Ali's airport problem, "It was Seth who was trying to help me,"Ali testified.
That help, Ali told the jury, involved Williams making a call from the D.A.'s office to a high-ranking police official, Joseph Sullivan, to see if he could help Ali.
So when Ali made his next overseas trip, thanks to Seth Williams, a "police officer was there waiting for me," when Ali arrived at the Philadelphia airport.
But even with a police escort, Al was detained for a secondary screening. This time, however, it took only 10 minutes, instead of up to two hours.
Were you happy with that, the prosecutor asked.
"Of course," Ali replied.
Ali said he also asked Williams to help him with the drug case of a friend who was facing prison time.
"Boss man, sorry to bother you, remember a few months back, I asked you if you can help with a case for a friend of mine" who was a DJ at a night club, Ali texted Williams. "He has a court tomorrow and he is looking at 1.5-3 years in jail plus 6 years probation! Is there anything you can do for him?"
"I will look into it," Williams wrote Ali. Then the D.A. asked if the DJ had already pleaded guilty to the drug charges filed by the Philly D.A.'s office.
The answer was yes.
"If he pleaded guilty, and from the sentence it seems that there is a mandatory sentence," Williams texted Ali, "There is very little I can do the day before without it looking extremely suspicious . . . "So Williams did nothing. While he continued to take the money and the free vacations and the sofa.
So Rufus is great at shakedowns. But where's the quid pro quo?
The day in court ended with Ali still on the stand. Tomorrow, when court resumes at 9:30 a.m., Ali will face cross-examination.