for BigTrial.net
It was a slam-dunk criminal case, complete with a suspect caught on video, and a confession.
But it wasn't enough for the District Attorney's office under Larry Krasner.
On Oct 8th, cops from the 26th Police District apprehended Joseph Scott after a foot chase. They showed Scott a surveillance video capturing him and an associate trying to steal a catalytic converter.
Scott waived his Miranda rights and gave a statement saying yes, that was him on the video. He was the guy behind the wheel of a Honda at 5 a.m. on Oct. 4th, who transported Michael Soder to 2600 Coral Street, so Soder could unsuccessfully attempt to cut the catalytic converter off of a 1993 Ford E250 van. The cops charged Scott, 35, of the 2000 block of East Letterly Street, with theft, criminal mischief, and criminal conspiracy.
Scott had a rap sheet featuring six arrests, including three thefts, two aggravated assaults, and one bust for narcotics. He's also been charged previously with carrying firearms. He was out on bail after being arrested for stealing another catalytic converter just two months earlier, and was due in court on Nov. 18th.
But when Scott's most recent arrest went to the district attorney's office for prosecution, Assistant District Attorney Joo Kim declined to prosecute the case, saying there was insufficient evidence.
The cops were furious. But frequently under District Attorney Larry Krasner, this is how the criminal justice system works. The criminal goes free, the cops get treated like the enemy, and the victim is an afterthought.
Assistant District Attorney Kim did not respond to a request for comment on why he declined to prosecute the Oct. 8th arrest of Joseph Scott for stealing a catalytic converter.
As usual, also not responding to a request for comment was Kim's boss, District Attorney Larry Krasner, and Jane Roh, Krasner's alleged spokesperson.
When Jospeh Scott was busted on Oct. 8th for attempting to steal a catalytic converter, it wasn't his first rodeo.
On Aug. 5th, the cops arrested Scott and charged him with theft, criminal mischief, criminal conspiracy, receiving stolen property, carrying firearms in public, carrying an unlicensed firearm, and possession of an instrument of crime.
Those are the charges that Scott is due in court to answer on Nov. 18th.
.
Scott wasn't a stranger to Patrol Officer Francis Leaden, one of the cops who arrested him on Aug. 5th. On April 5th, Leaden and another officer arrested Scott after they found a stolen catalytic converter in his Mercury Grand Marquis that was sawed off of a stolen U-Haul truck.
Again, the crime was caught on surveillance video. When the cops searched Scott's Mercury, they also found a .380 handgun with a magazine containing four live rounds. Scott was charged with carrying an unlicensed firearm, two counts of theft, criminal conspiracy, carrying a firearm in public, unauthorized use of an auto, and criminal mischief.
But Scott is still out there on the street, free to commit more crimes.
The district attorney's frequent decisions not to prosecute arrests made by the cops -- known formally as declinations -- has been a prior source of controversy, because of official lies emanating from Krasner's office.
On June 19, 2019, William J. Heeney, then a candidate for City Council, filed a right-to-know request seeking the "number of cases declined by the District Attorney Charging Unit from January 2018 to present, and documented reasons for the declination."
On June 26, 2019, the district attorney's office requested a 30-day extension to reply to Heeney's request.
On July 29, 2019, the D.A.'s office, with Krasner's name stamped on the top of their official stationary, sent Heeney a formal denial of his request, written by an appropriately named assistant district attorney, Benjamin Jackal.
"Your request is denied," Jackal wrote Heeney. "The DAO does not have possession, custody or control of records responsive to your request."
"Your request is denied," Jackal wrote Heeney. "The DAO does not have possession, custody or control of records responsive to your request."
This was a lie. As one city official subsequently wrote Big Trial, "There is a weekly report generated to a select number of personnel in the Police Department and the District Attorney's Office via email documenting every declination (refusal by the District Attorney to prosecute a case) and the reason for the declination."
In response, Heeney sued the D.A.'s office in Philadelphia Common Pleas Court. In his Feb. 22nd lawsuit, Heeney wrote, "The reasons the District Attorney provides lack merit. They are mere attempts to hide the underlying progressive agenda the District Attorney's office wishes to maintain in the city of Philadelphia."
The citizens of Philadelphia, Heeney wrote, "who are supposed to be protected by the office of the District Attorney, are entitled to know why its chief law enforcement officer is declining to prosecute criminal cases."
But Krasner has never released those records because he doesn't want the public to know about the 2,562 cases his office declined to prosecute during 2018, his first year in office. These cases run the gamut of crimes, including aggravated assault, prostitution, bringing weapons to school, robbery and rape.
But records kept by the cops show that declinations by the D.A.'s office are stacking up this year.
For example, in the past five weeks, from Oct. 5th to Nov. 8th, the district attorney's office under Krasner has declined 136 cases for prosecution, or some 27 cases a week.
The cases turned down for prosecution during that five-week period include 18 alleged cases of aggravated assault, six alleged simple assaults, nine alleged burglaries, seven alleged prostitution cases, two alleged robberies, two alleged arsons, three alleged violations of the Uniform Firearms Act, and one case of alleged terroristic threats.
That's one way to lower the crime rate.
Assistant District Attorney Kim is a major player in issuing the declinations; of the 136 declinations, Kim is responsible for 42 of them.
As you might imagine, ADA Kim is not a popular guy with the cops.
"The same ADA systematically declines cases for thefts and burglaries of frivolous or improper reasons," one cop said, "and many officers and detectives have complained about him."
But in ADA Kim's defense, he might be doing just what the boss ordered.